Cheaper House

Is it better to buy a cheaper house and renovate?

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    If you are currently considering making a financial investment in the purchase of a new property, you have probably already given some thought to the potential benefits of purchasing a building that is a little bit older and then renovating it. The purchase of a "fixer-upper" may be a reliable way to turn a more profitable return on your investment; however, this strategy is not for everyone, and there may be aspects of such a large commitment that you haven't already considered. Moreover, buying a "fixer-upper" may require you to make financial sacrifices that you haven't yet considered. Even though every new home or property is going to require a different amount of work to make it match your needs, the prospect of buying a property that you know in advance will cost you a significant amount of additional financial outlay may be discouraging you from going ahead and making the investment.

    You adore your home, but there just isn't enough room for everyone. You are interested in moving, but you have strong feelings for your neighbours. Your home has a lot of character, but it's time to give it a fresh coat of paint. You've decided that you want to switch houses, but it would be ideal if you could take your garden with you. These are the conundrums that force homeowners to make a significant decision: should they buy a new home or should they renovate their current home to make it more suitable for their requirements?

    Looking for the best home repairs services? Look no further! Hitch Property Constructions has you covered.

    Home Repair FAQs

    A repair is maintenance that takes place to restore a typecertificated product to "condition for safe operation." And, an alteration is maintenance that is performed that adds to and/or removes from the type-certificated product's configuration..

    One of the most common new construction Home defects is overlooked paint. You may find that some areas of a newly-built home have not been properly painted, such as basement areas, utility closets, and other out-of-the-way areas. Touch up paint is also done at the very end of construction.

    However, the difference between repair and maintenance work is that repairs aim to restore functionality while maintenance looks to preserve functionality. Put simply, repairs are done after downtime to minimize losses, while maintenance is done to prevent unexpected asset downtime.

    Repainting the exterior of your residential rental property: By itself, the cost of painting the exterior of a building is generally a currently deductible repair expense because merely painting isn't an improvement under the capitalization rules.

    The most glaring issue has to deal with the foundation. When to walk away from foundation issues? Horizontal or diagonal cracks measuring more than 1/4 of an inch is a good reason to walk away.

    Buying a Fixer-Upper vs. Buying New: Which Is Better?


    You might want to move in without having to do any work, or you might not mind giving a couple of rooms a facelift so that they are more in line with your aesthetic. You could also consider purchasing a house that is in need of significant renovation but already possesses solid structural components but sells for a lower price.

    The following factors should be taken into account when determining whether purchasing a house that needs some work or one that has been recently built or renovated is the better option for you:

    Cheaper House

    Fixer-Uppers Are a Work in Progress

    Fixer-uppers are frequently the best option for first-time homebuyers whose spending capacity is constrained and for people who enjoy the challenge of taking on a renovation project.

    It doesn't matter if you're looking at fixer-uppers because their prices are within your budget or because the thought of undertaking a major renovation excites you; the scale of the work that needs to be done must be something that you are willing to take on. If you are working with a limited budget, you may need to do many of the renovations yourself or stage them room by room while you save up the necessary funds. A house that needs some work might not be the best choice for you if you don't find that appealing.

    If the prospect of doing the necessary work on a fixer-upper doesn't appeal to you, you should concentrate your search on newly built homes and renovated properties that meet all of your requirements. Focus on "fixer-uppers" if you like the idea of making immediate improvements to the space in order to personalise it.

    You'll Be Renovating Anyway.

    Unless you are moving into a brand-new house that has been custom-built for you, there is a good chance that you will be conducting at least some minor home improvements. According to Raf Howery, founder and CEO of home information and data company Kukun, an estimated sixty percent of all homes bought get remodelled to some extent. This is true regardless of the living condition of the home at the time it was sold.

    Even if a kitchen or living room doesn't feel dated, you may still want to paint the walls, replace the flooring, and restain or add cabinets, for example. In many cases, this is something that should be done. According to Howery, "the majority of people will be required to affix that stamp on their home."

    If you want to make changes and additions to your home, you might want to consider purchasing an existing home that is already on the market and selling it for a lower price. This will help you make up for the additional money you will spend on renovations.

    Fixer-Uppers Require a Lot of Planning

    You should probably start planning your renovation as soon as you purchase a fixer-upper that requires a significant amount of work. This includes determining your total budget for the project, figuring out the scope of the work that needs to be done, and developing a timeline.

    In order to successfully complete the renovation, you will need the assistance of a team of trained professionals, which could include a larger number of people than you initially anticipated. It's possible that you'll need a construction insurance policy to protect the property during your renovation if it will take a long time and involve a lot of heavy construction. But your insurance company can also be a resource for determining priorities in the rehabilitation of the house. "We can help you pick out those things (in the home) that might lead to deferred maintenance issues," your insurance company may tell you.

    Buy a New Property or Renovate - What’s Cheaper?

    If you are faced with the challenge of deciding between purchasing a new home and simply staying put and renovating the one you already own because the one you have is out of date, the scope of the work that needs to be done on your home will determine which of these two options is the more cost-effective choice for you.

    What Are the Costs Involved in Buying a New House?

    Aside from the obvious cost of the purchase price of your dream home, there will be a few other up-front costs involved. Some of these costs you may be familiar with already, including the following:

    • Stamp duty: You will be required to pay stamp duty again with any title transfer, which is by far the most expensive cost to think about. You should plan for this cost. Try out our calculator for the stamp duty here.
    • Costs associated with refinancing: The amount of money you will have to pay to change the terms of your loan will depend on how flexible your loan is.
    • Application fees for home loans are the fees that a lender will charge you in order to apply for or establish a loan. In some cases, this requirement won't apply; if you'd like assistance negotiating this with your Home Loan Specialist, let them know.
    • Fees for attorneys and conveyancers are a cost of buying a new home that cannot be avoided, just as they were the first time you purchased a home or other property.
    • The majority of real estate agents will base their commision fees on a percentage of the sale price of your home, typically ranging between 1 and 2 percent.
    • Expenses incurred for building inspections: It is always important to arrange building and pest inspections to ensure the structural integrity of a home, which is something that you will need to do with your new home.
    • Whether it's due to hiring movers or simply making the additional purchases you'll need in your new home, moving will cost money. This is true regardless of whether you decide to hire movers or simply make the additional purchases you'll need.

    What Are the Costs Involved in Renovating?

    When you are doing renovations, you will also have a lot of costs to consider, and you will need to make sure that the following are covered in your budget:

    • The cost of the building materials and labour will differ depending on the scale of your renovations. Additionally, you will need to factor in the cost of hiring builders and contractors.
    • Expenses incurred for employing a variety of professionals: This might include a project manager, designer, architect, and structural engineer, but it all depends on what your specific needs are. Learn more about the experts that you might need to hire by reading more about them here.
    • Paying for the council: It is always a good idea to check with your local council before beginning any renovations to see if you will be required to pay any fees for doing so. Certain renovations need to be approved by the council before they can be started. In most cases, the magnitude of this fee will be determined by the total cost of your remodelling project.
    • Rental fees: If you need to move out of your home during the period of the renovation, you will need to consider the additional costs of rent on top of everything else. If you are able to stay in your home during the renovation, you will save money.
    • Emotional expenses include: Home improvement projects can come with their own unique set of stresses and strains. If you want to live in your house while you renovate it, you should be prepared to spend some of your time there feeling like you're in the middle of a construction zone.

    Things to Consider Before Buying a Property to Renovate

    According to Hagerty, the following are the fundamental "bottom lines" that a buyer should consider when contemplating the purchase of any renovation property, including Grandma's house:

    Ask if the Property Was Ever Vacant.

    If that is the case, check to see that it has not deteriorated. If you are fortunate enough to find Grandma's old home, you can assume that it has never been vacant, but that it has seen only light use in recent years. As a result, it is probably in excellent condition where it counts.

    Look Past the Surface.

    Many of the historic homes that are being sold as having been renovated are actually owned by banks and may have lain empty for many years. Some enhancements, such as stainless steel appliances and granite countertops, give the impression that the property is of higher quality. Nevertheless, it's possible that they were completed in a hurry while other, more pressing concerns, such as the roof, the HVAC system, and the electrical wires, were ignored.

    Inspect the Bones

    The replacement of the roof and gutters, windows, and HVAC system are going to be the most fundamental (and frequently the most expensive) renovations that need to be done. The majority of the time, these are the kinds of problems that will cause your offer to be null and void during your inspection, so it is in your best interest to eliminate homes that have these problems right from the start.

    Brave the Scary Basements

    There is nothing that can cause more damage to a house in a shorter amount of time than an issue with water, so check the basement for signs of water and, if necessary, either pass on the property or budget for a drainage system.

    Keep Future Renovations in Mind.

    If you are certain that you will eventually prefer an open floor plan, it is best to have your contractor tear down walls before you even move in.

    Check out our Melbourne home repairs to help you to build your dream house.

    Consider your ROI

    Some renovations, such as finishing a basement, do not always result in an increase in resale value that is proportional to the amount of money spent on the project. Others, such as installing a full bathroom or a half bathroom on the main floor, will do so.

    Consider timing

    A renovation could take a contractor anywhere from 30 to 90 days to finish depending on the amount of work that needs to be done. During the time that the renovation is being done, it is absolutely necessary to have a living arrangement that is flexible or to be able to go month to month with your landlord.

    Find the Right Person for the Job.

    conducting interviews with at least three to five licenced contractors and obtaining quotes from each of them.

    In light of this, we have compiled a list of the most likely advantages and disadvantages that you should think about when purchasing a property to renovate.


    Create the Home of Your Dreams for the Same Total Price

    It can be very challenging to find the ideal property in the location you desire, but if you can afford it, purchasing a property that is in disrepair in the area you want to live in could be an option you should think about. If you are serious about turning a profit from your home renovation project, you should buy the worst house you can find on the best street that you can afford. This will give you the most potential for adding value to the property. Due to the property's current state, it is highly unlikely that many people will be interested in purchasing it; therefore, the price should reflect this reality. As an individual renovator, you will not have any influence over an area or the street, but you will have complete control over the transformation of the house, including the option to completely rebuild it if necessary.

    Because the majority of the profit is made during the purchase rather than as a result of the work done to it, the price that you pay is extremely important. In an ideal scenario, you will want to invest in real estate that possesses potential that others have not yet recognised, so that you do not have to pay a premium price for it. Because the potential margin for profit is likely to be relatively small unless you are purchasing a large property, you should think about the maximum amount that you are willing to pay before making any purchases.

    Even Smaller Projects Can Make Your New House Feel Like Home.

    It's not necessary for every "renovation" project to be a massive undertaking or to have the goal of making a lot of money. Taking on a project can be a nice way to create a home that you do love, which is a nice option to consider if you are having trouble finding a property that you truly like. Minor flaws in a property do not have an effect on its value in and of themselves; however, when taken together, they will prevent the property from being sold at the best possible price. The following are common flaws that will discourage many potential buyers, but which can be easily remedied by any competent do-it-yourselfer:

    • Peeling paint


    • Problems with the doors and windows squeaking or sticking


    • latches not functioning properly on the doors


    • Sealants in the kitchen and bathroom that are mouldy


    • Dripping taps


    • Loose tiles


    • Sewer smells


    • Broken or damaged windows


    • Floors and steps that make a squeaking sound


    • Ceilings and plaster that have cracks in them also.


    • Lifting flooring


    • A decor that has seen better days, complete with artex ceilings and dado rails!


    You’ll Likely Run Over Budget (And Out of Patience!)

    The potential for increasing the value of a property through renovation is substantial; however, there is always the risk of overspending on the project without actually increasing the property's value. It is not a given that you will receive the same amount of money back even though you have improved the property by spending thousands of dollars. In order to successfully finish a home renovation project, you need to have a sensible outlook on what you hope to accomplish and a solid understanding of the paths that are likely to lead you there. You need to be very disciplined with the spending plan that you've established, as this is arguably the most important thing of all.

    It is recommended that you add an additional 20 percent to your initial budget in order to be ready for any unanticipated issues, particularly if structural work is required, as this will allow you to be more prepared. A simple rule that could be followed is to not spend money on making significant changes to the property if those changes will not add to its value. To be successful in this endeavour, it may be beneficial to work with Romans property experts located in your area.

    It’s Easy to Underestimate Just How Much ‘Renovation’ Needs Completing.

    It is very important to begin the process by selecting the ideal piece of real estate. You should be honest with yourself about the amount of work that you are able to put into a home before you buy it, even though you might be interested in purchasing a home that needs a lot of work. Let's say, for example, that you decide to put your money into an older piece of real estate. If this is the case, you need to be aware that certain older buildings might be more difficult to insure and might demand alternative remodelling strategies to prevent further damage, which typically results in increased costs.

    There’s a Risk You Won’t Add Real Value.

    In addition, you need to be aware that there is a cap on the amount of value that can be added to your property through renovation. It is more common for the demand for properties to reflect the popularity of the surrounding neighbourhood than the interiors of the homes themselves; therefore, you should make sure that you do not make drastic, significant changes without first considering how much value they will add. Do you remember the old adage that advised people to purchase the home with the worst location on the best street rather than the best location on the worst street? This is absolutely true in this situation, even though the "best house" still needs a lot of work done to it.

    DIY vs. tradesmen

    You shouldn't be in a hurry to commit to the purchase of a house that requires extensive remodelling. Even after conducting research and locating a piece of real estate that has the potential to fulfil all of your needs, you must still think about who is going to carry out the work. Because you are likely to spend a significant amount of money on the project, it is essential that you locate reputable tradespeople, regardless of whether you have previously collaborated with them or whether you have been given a recommendation for them. Do your research; you should never choose the least expensive alternative simply because you believe it will help you save money.

    If you live a long distance away, are unable to manage the project yourself due to other commitments, or are simply inexperienced in property renovation, investing in a project manager to oversee the project is a good idea. This is especially true if you are renovating a property for the first time. Project managers will make certain that the builders complete the work according to your specifications, which will increase the likelihood that the project will stay within its allotted budget. On the other hand, you will be required to pay for the expertise that they provide.

    Is It Wiser to Renovate or Buy a New House?


    A knowledgeable real estate agent will tell you that location, location, location is the most important factor. This is an important consideration to take into account when deciding whether to build new or renovate. Renovating might be the better option for you if you have strong feelings of attachment to the community in which you live, as well as to the people who live nearby, the amenities available, and the sense that this location serves as your home. Better yet, if the location of your current home is in a hip district where real estate prices are climbing, investing in renovations may also be a financially savvy move for you to make. First, you should get some cost estimates for the remodelling project, and then you should figure out the fair market value of the finished project. If the increase in sale price will more than cover the expense of the renovations, then the choice may be an easy one to make.


    There is one component that is common to both the process of purchasing a new residence and that of renovating an existing one. They both need monetary resources and financial backing. When you buy a new home, you'll need to apply for a new mortgage. It is possible that now is not the right time for you to submit an application for a mortgage if you have recently switched jobs, have racked up significant debt, or are planning to make other significant investments in the near future. It is possible that you could qualify for a home equity loan to cover the cost of home improvements if you have already built up a respectable amount of equity in your current residence. Keep in mind that a home equity loan will also result in additional closing costs, some of which may include credit reports, appraisals, and title insurance. In addition to the costs of purchasing a new home and selling your current residence, other associated costs include real estate commissions, seller closing costs, and the costs of transporting your belongings from one place to another.


    The desire for a new house is frequently driven by the aspiration to acquire a larger living space. When expanding the living space in an existing home, there are two directions one can go: up or out. It's possible that building a second story onto a home with only one level would be a good idea, but there are a couple of things that need to be taken into consideration first. To begin, you have to determine whether or not the home's foundation is capable of supporting the additional weight or if it needs to be reinforced. The second factor to take into account is whether or not the zoning regulations in your community permit you to construct higher. The total square footage of the home will increase, but the yard will lose some of its acreage due to the addition. If you decide to build an addition onto your existing home, you will need to ensure that you have sufficient yard space and that the plans adhere to any necessary setbacks or right-of-ways.


    The decision-making process involves a number of tangible aspects, including finances, location, and the actual brick-and-mortar components of a home. When weighing the benefits of purchasing a new home versus those of remodelling an existing one, however, it is important to take into account the intangible aspects of each option. A renovation is a long and difficult process that requires patience and flexibility on the part of the homeowner. After a few months of living in less-than-ideal conditions, such as having flying dust, the constant sound of power tools, and a plethora of contractors walking through your home, your nerves may be frayed to the point where you can no longer function normally. On the other hand, if the thought of packing up and leaving the cosy comforts of your current home gives you the heebie-jeebies and makes you feel like you can't control them, then the discomforts of a renovation may pale in comparison to what you'll be going through. Before you put a "for sale" sign in the front yard, you should determine what kinds of things you can and cannot put up with.

    When Should I Sell Up and Buy?

    Your financial goals should be taken into consideration whenever you make a decision regarding the purchase of an existing home or the construction of a new one. If you just want to make a few minor changes, it may be more cost-effective to renovate your existing home rather than buy a new one. If you are already living in the location of your dreams and you intend to live there for the long term, staying put and making some changes to your current home can be more practical than buying a new property. This can be a major factor in the decision-making process.

    In addition to that, if the value of real estate in your region is increasing, it might be beneficial for you to make improvements to your home now so that you can take advantage of any capital growth that may occur in the future. In the event that you do choose to relocate, you can turn this home into an investment property. Nevertheless, when it comes to renovations, you need to carefully consider your costs to make sure that you are not overcapitalizing.

    We have an extensive range of home repairs Melbourne services at Hitch Property Constructions.

    When Should I Stay Put and Renovate?

    On the other hand, if you just want to make a few minor changes, it might be more cost-effective to renovate the home you already own rather than moving. In addition, if you are already residing in the neighbourhood of your dreams and have plans to remain there for an extended period of time, it may be more practical for you to remain in your current home while making some upgrades to it rather than purchasing a new one.

    In addition to this, if the value of real estate in your neighbourhood is on the rise, it might make more financial sense to invest in home improvements now, before the capital growth that will result from these improvements. Nevertheless, when it comes to renovations, you need to carefully consider your costs to make sure that you are not overcapitalizing.

    In other words, if you budget for a renovation, have enough patience, vision, and elbow grease, you might be able to see a nice return on your investment, in addition to a few inherited trinkets (like the Elvis clock) along the way!

    Scroll to Top